Who in India is really poor? - 26 Sep 11

26 Sep 2011  Vrindavan, India

Category: Society

Children at Lunch

Last week the Planning Commission of India, a government institution that looks at how much money India has and recommends how much should be spent in which sectors, suggested to update the Indian criteria for who lives below the poverty line and who doesn’t. They are of the opinion that everybody who has enough money to spend more than 32 Rupees per day in a town or more than 26 Rupees a day in the countryside cannot be considered poor. 32 Rupees are currently about 0.64 US-Dollar. This has caused another uproar in media, among activists and of course among the general population.

According to the new suggestion, you are only poor if you daily spend less than Rs 5.5 on cereals, Rs 1.02 on pulses, Rs 1.55 on edible oil, Rs 1.95 on vegetables and 44 Paise on fruits. You are well off and not poor in this country if you spend more than Rs 49.10 a month on your rent in a city like Delhi and more than Rs 61.30 a month on clothing.

Who can live nicely in this amount of money? Nobody! They want to say if anyone earns more than 32 Rupees a day, he is not poor but the reality is that he will hardly have enough to eat, not to mention clothing and health care! But for the government he will be living above the poverty line and so they don’t need to care about him.

I tried to find out how many people actually live below the poverty line in India. The problem is that there is not any clear number! When you look up ‘Poverty in India’, you find at least five different committees, reports and organizations that give you different figures according to different criteria. The World Bank estimate of 2005 says that 41.6% of the population is below the international poverty line of 1.25 US-Dollar per day but at the same time the World Bank mentions that an estimated 80% earn less than 2 US-Dollars per day. The Tendulkar Committee counts 37% of the population as poor while the N. C. Saxena Committee mentions a figure of 50%. The Arjun Sengupta Report states that 77% of the population lives on less than 20 Rupees a day, which is currently about 0.40 US-Dollar. The only thing that seems to be clear is there are more poor people even only in North and East India than there are in the 26 poorest African nations!

The government officially accepted the estimate of the Tendulkar Committee with 37% of all Indians living below the poverty line. This is not surprising as it is the report with the lowest figures and officially the government supports those who live below the poverty line. We see that this support in reality never reaches those whom it is intended to help but the less poor people India officially has, the better it is for the government! It is just a game of numbers. This suggestion to update the criteria for the poverty line is thus seen as only this: a way to reduce the official number of people who live below the poverty line. Nobody earns more money than before, people still have to fight to make ends meet but India suddenly has a lot less poor people.

Can this be right?

Share this post on: 

Tags:: Money, Society , Government, Hunger, India, Poor

5 Comments

Posted By Swami Balendu

Swami Balendu

Older Entries

Children get Clothes

Happy Diwali also for our Children

Happy Diwali to all of you! The Ashram celebrat...

Breakfast

Apra's German Grandparents in Vrindavan - 28 Oct 1...

Apra’s German Grandparents in Vrindavan - 28...

Distributing Workbooks

New Workbooks for our smallest School Children - 2...

It is Saturday, the weekend has started and for ou...

Fear

Caught in a Web of your own Fears? Here is what to...

Sometimes it is strange for me to see how much fea...

Shirodhara

Shirodhara - Ayurvedic Treatment against Stress, D...

A whole lot is going on, as always, and we are bus...

Peaceful Conversation

A Call for open Communication - because it helps! ...

I have always been a believer in open communicatio...

atheist meeting vrindavan

Thanks to religious Leaders, a cancelled Event mad...

So yesterday was my 45th birthday and definitely a...

Ewai Masti

National Convention on Atheism in religious Town V...

Until now, I have not told you yet about a program...

Balendu and Apra

Treasuring every precious Moment with my Baby - 5 ...

Today I woke up in the morning, as usual next to m...

Money

Please read if the Aim of your Life is all about M...

I yesterday wrote about parents who want to suppor...

Related Blogs

Children at Lunch

Beating of Hillary Adams - Exposing global Problem...

Yesterday I wrote about domestic violence against ...

Women, Honour and Sexuality

What is the Connection between a Woman's Honour an...

While I was writing about honour killing and the r...

65 Percent of Population without Toilet - 3 Jan 11

Now we have entered the second decade of the 21st ...

Satellite Dish

Life is a Struggle - but TV is a must! - 8 Apr 14

I yesterday started writing down the experiences t...

Gender Equality

No, cleaning the House is not unmanly at all! - 9 ...

When I was yesterday writing about the school book...

President Patil and Prince Charles

Commonwealth Games Inauguration - Prince Charles o...

The Commonwealth Games 2010 are planned to start i...

Men helping in Household

Jobs for both Genders but Housework remains the Ta...

Yesterday I started writing about gender roles and...

No Men allowed

Women have Love, Men only Lust - how Feminists wor...

In Hindu scriptures it is said that women have eig...

Women of the Family

Why do we celebrate International Women's Day? - 8...

Today is International Women’s Day. This is ...

Sex Scandal in Vrindavan

Media Should Not Create Stories that Ruin Lives - ...

Today I want to write about a local story, which i...

Swami ji Ramona & Yashendu

Native Americans and Aborigines - Similarities in ...

Today in the morning I asked Ramona a little bit a...

Bavaria

Overkill of Democracy - 20 May 14

I believe we all can agree that democracy is the b...

Khajuraho

Will we need a Men's Rights Movement for Gender Eq...

When one talks about expectations, relationships, ...

Landscape

Don't let Society force you - it's your own Life! ...

When I yesterday wrote about the life plan that mo...

Friends at the Ashram

Unique, different, you are like nobody else - 30 M...

Yesterday I mentioned that we cannot all like the ...

Children at Lunch

Who in India is really poor? - 26 Sep 11

Last week the Planning Commission of India, a gove...

Flowers in the Ashram Garden

Violence at Home with the Excuse of improving weak...

When talking about corporal punishment, as I did i...

Pope about Child Abuse Scandal

Pope says Child Abuse was normal because of Societ...

Still before Christmas I read a website article ab...

Formula One Car Races Polluting Environment

Formula One Car Race - Fun in Dying, Injuring and ...

This week I by chance saw some news on the interne...

Domestic Violence

Domestic Violence in India - Senseless and cruel B...

The picture that you can see above was posted in f...

Have something to say? Post your comment

Comments are moderated and will be allowed if they are about the topic and not abusive.

Comments

In my opinion this Planning Commission of India has a lack of contact with reality. How can you use numbers to describe everyday life and its consequences of poor people? Being poor doesn't have to mean the same for everyone. Where do these standards come from? Is there any member of the Commission that ever really faced poverty?

Reply By Mirela on August 20, 2012 04:15


If they spent the money to relieve poverty that they spend on studying it, that would be a great headstart to resolving the problem.

Reply By nothingprofound on September 27, 2011 08:15


Reply To your Comment

:) If that money could just reach where is should!

By Ramona on September 28, 2011

no, but sadly enough - it's the "name of the game"!

Reply By Manfred Samui on September 27, 2011 07:24


These are ridiculous numbers! I cannot imagine anybody, even with the comparably low food prices in India, surviving on 32 Rupees. You still need to pay for some other things like electricity, heating or cooking gas etc! That is the game of politics and numbers though, just as you said. In Germany we have seen this with the number of number of unemployed. they introduced a new system to help people and thus cut the number of unemployed down drastically.

Reply By Christine Schmid on September 27, 2011 04:02


Load More Comments

Get Swami Ji's Diary via Email


Enter your email-address to get news by email!

Feedburner
Blogs
2960
Comments
7384
Topics
83